Skip to main content

Table 1 Common misconceptions about natural selection

From: Teaching natural selection in early elementary classrooms: can a storybook intervention reduce teleological misunderstandings?

Misconception

Example answers to: Why did giraffes evolve longer necks?

Explicit TE

 Basic TE

The giraffes developed longer necks in order to reach food that grew on tall trees OR Giraffes with shorter necks developed longer necks because they needed them to reach food

 Elaborated effort TE

Giraffes got long necks because they tried to reach the food

 Elaborated agent TE

Nature gave giraffes longer necks to help them

Ambiguous explanation

 Transformation

Giraffes with short necks changed into giraffes with long necks

 Development

Giraffes born with short necks grew longer necks as they got older