Skip to main content

Table 2 Summary of review of citations reporting new implementations of each instrument

From: Applying measurement standards to evolution education assessment instruments

Instrument Abbr. Original population Reliability (R) of original instrument on original population Validity (V) of original instrument on original population # Publications that used instrument (#DiffVers.Only, #DiffPopOnly, #BothDiff) New evidence of R for new version and/or new pop New evidence of V for new version and/or new pop
Evolution concept test (natural selection) ECT UG-NM, MW None Content
Substantive
27 (3, 2, 20) Internal consistency (1, 3%);
Inter-rater reliability (1, 3%)
Content (1, 3%)
Substantive (1, 3%)
Concept inventory of natural selection CINS UG-NM, SW Internal consistency (3) Content
Substantive
Internal structure
31(1, 19, 10) Internal consistency (2, 6%) Substantive (2, 6%)
Measure of the acceptance of the theory of evolution MATE HS-T, MW (1999)
UG-NM, S (2007)
Internal consistency (HS-T, MW; 2)
Internal consistency (UG-NM, S; 4)
Stability (UG-NM, S)
Content (HS-T, MW)
Internal structure (HS-T, MW)
Internal structure (UG-NM, S; 2)
External structure (UG-NM, S)
88 (0, 41, 38) Internal consistency (48, 54%) Content (9, 10%)
Internal structure (8, 9%)
External structure (1, 1%)
Measure of understanding of macroevolution MUM UG-M, UG-MA, SE Internal consistency (2) Content 6 (0, 2, 1) Internal consistency (1, 16%) Content (1, 16%)
Internal structure (1, 16%)
Knowledge of evolution exam KEE UG, MW None None 7 (0, 2, 1) None None
Evolution attitudes and literacy survey EALS UG-P, MW (LF)
UG-M, MW (SF)
Internal consistency Content
Internal structure
8 (3, 0, 4) Internal consistency (1, 12%) Internal structure (1, 12%)
Accessing contextual reasoning about natural selection ACORNS UG, MW Internal consistency
Inter-rater agreement
Content
Substantive
External structure
9 (0, 0, 0) N/A N/A
Inventory of student evolution acceptance I-SEA HS-S, UG, W Internal consistency Content
Internal structure
3 (0, 1, 0) None None
Evo-Devo concept inventory EvoDevo
CI
UG-M, UG-MA, MW, NE, S Internal consistency
Stability
Alternate forms
Content
Substantive
External structure
1(0, 0, 0) N/A N/A
Assessment tool for evaluating evolution knowledge ATEEK UG-M, UG-MA, MW Inter-rater agreement None 2 (0, 0, 0) None None
Genetic drift inventory GEDI UG-MA, NW, SE, MW Stability
Internal consistency
Content
Substantive
Generalization
1 (0, 0, 0) N/A N/A
Generalized acceptance of evolution evaluation GAENE HS-S, UG, USA Internal consistency Content
Internal structure
1 (0, 0, 0) None N/A
Concept assessment of natural selection CANS UG-M, W Internal consistency
Stability
Content
Substantive
0 (0, 0, 0) N/A N/A